Skip to content
Open every day · 6:00am–3:00pm

Upper East Side · 1111 First Avenue

Hand-rolled. Kettle-boiled. Baked fresh daily.

New York's best bagels, baked fresh every morning on First Avenue — and out of the oven before the city wakes up.

A paper bag of fresh New York bagels with an open-faced lox and cream cheese bagel in front
Open every day · 6:00am–3:00pm

Neighborhood favorites

Start with a classic

The orders that keep First Avenue coming back — ready for pickup or delivery.

  • Everything bagel with cream cheese, smoked salmon, red onion and capers

    Lox and cream cheese

    Smoked salmon and cream cheese on a fresh bagel — the New York classic.

    Order
  • Bacon, egg and cheese sandwich on a toasted sesame bagel

    Bacon, egg and cheese

    On any bagel, roll or croissant. Served all day.

    Order
  • Toasted bagel halves spread with scallion cream cheese

    Bagel with cream cheese

    Plain, scallion, vegetable, jalapeño, blueberry, strawberry or lox spread.

    Order
  • A pile of everything, sesame, plain, poppy, cinnamon raisin and pumpernickel bagels

    Half dozen or dozen

    Grab a half dozen or a dozen for the office, the house or the week.

    Order
An assortment of seeded bagels on baking paper

The New York way

Three steps. No shortcuts.

  1. Hand-rolled

    Every bagel is rolled and shaped by hand — the way New York bagels are supposed to be made.

  2. Kettle-boiled

    A dip in the kettle before the oven. That's where the shine and the chew come from.

  3. Baked every morning

    Out of the oven before the city wakes up — every single morning on First Avenue.

Our bagels

  • Plain
  • Sesame
  • Everything
  • Poppy
  • Onion
  • Garlic
  • Salt
  • Cinnamon raisin
  • Whole wheat
  • Pumpernickel
  • Egg

Straight from Google

What the Neighborhood Says

Real reviews from our Google listing, updated automatically.

Order ahead

Skip the line.

Order online for pickup or delivery — your freshly baked Upper East Side bagel, ready when you are.

  • Pickup 7:00am–2:30pm
  • Delivery 7:00am–2:30pm
Takeout box of smoked salmon bagels with coffee and orange juice

Visit us

Authentic New York Bagel Shop near First Ave

Fresh Bagel is on the corner of First Avenue and 59th Street in the heart of the Upper East Side. The best bagel shop near First Avenue — street parking available, and the closest subway is the 4/5/6 at 59th Street.

1111 First AvenueNew York, NY 10065

Upper East Side, Manhattan

(212) 371-4907

Hours

Open every day · 6:00am–3:00pm
Store
Every day, 6:00am–3:00pm
Pickup
Every day, 7:00am–2:30pm
Delivery
Every day, 7:00am–2:30pm

Getting here

  • Subway: 4/5/6 at 59th Street
  • Street parking available

1111 First Avenue, New York, NY 10065

Open in Google Maps