Upper East Side · 1111 First Avenue
Hand-rolled. Kettle-boiled. Baked fresh daily.
New York's best bagels, baked fresh every morning on First Avenue — and out of the oven before the city wakes up.
- Open daily 6am–3pm
- Pickup & delivery 7am–2:30pm
- (212) 371-4907

Neighborhood favorites
Start with a classic
The orders that keep First Avenue coming back — ready for pickup or delivery.
The New York way
Three steps. No shortcuts.
Hand-rolled
Every bagel is rolled and shaped by hand — the way New York bagels are supposed to be made.
Kettle-boiled
A dip in the kettle before the oven. That's where the shine and the chew come from.
Baked every morning
Out of the oven before the city wakes up — every single morning on First Avenue.
Our bagels
- Plain
- Sesame
- Everything
- Poppy
- Onion
- Garlic
- Salt
- Cinnamon raisin
- Whole wheat
- Pumpernickel
- Egg
Straight from Google
What the Neighborhood Says
Real reviews from our Google listing, updated automatically.
Order ahead
Skip the line.
Order online for pickup or delivery — your freshly baked Upper East Side bagel, ready when you are.
- Pickup 7:00am–2:30pm
- Delivery 7:00am–2:30pm
Visit us
Authentic New York Bagel Shop near First Ave
Fresh Bagel is on the corner of First Avenue and 59th Street in the heart of the Upper East Side. The best bagel shop near First Avenue — street parking available, and the closest subway is the 4/5/6 at 59th Street.
Upper East Side, Manhattan
(212) 371-4907Hours
Open every day · 6:00am–3:00pm- Store
- Every day, 6:00am–3:00pm
- Pickup
- Every day, 7:00am–2:30pm
- Delivery
- Every day, 7:00am–2:30pm
Getting here
- Subway: 4/5/6 at 59th Street
- Street parking available
1111 First Avenue, New York, NY 10065
Open in Google Maps